73

COMMENTS

PRINT

TEXT SIZE:

A A A
Think back to New Years Eve, 1999.

Most of us were more worried about Y2K and the incoming Bush administration (damn you Nader!) than whether or or not it was a good time to buy a house.

If only we knew then, what we know now ... we probably would have bought in Fort Myers and have only made 0.5 percent over a 10-year period.

Using the most recent data from the National Assocation of Realtors, we were able to compile a list of the 10 strongest housing markets since 2000 and the 10 weakest. While the final numbers for the fourth quarter of 2009 won't be out until February, we think it's fairly safe to proclaim the winners and losers.

The big winner in the housing market appears to be ... drumroll ... the Northeast.

Strongest Markets of the '00s
Median Prices in Thousands of Dollars
2000 3Q 2009 Change Change Per Year
Allentown-Bethlehem-Easton, Pa.-N.J. 115.4 230.5 99.74% 9.97%
Baltimore-Towson, Md. 131.8 261.1 98.10% 9.81%
Trenton-Ewing, N.J. 150.9 291.2 92.98% 9.30%
Atlantic City, N.J. 116.3 223.0 91.75% 9.17%
Virginia Beach-Norfolk-Newport News, Va.-N.C. 112.3 215.0 91.45% 9.15%
Philadelphia-Camden-Wilmington, Penn.-N.J.-Del.-Md. 122.4 227.5 85.87% 8.59%
Edison, N.J. 188.2 343.8 82.68% 8.27%
Shreveport-Bossier City, La. 83.8 152.3 81.74% 8.17%
Washington-Arlington-Alexandria, D.C.-Va.-Md.-W.Va. 178.8 324.7 81.60% 8.16%
Nassau-Suffolk, N.Y. 214.0 384.9 79.86% 7.99%

Six of the top 10 strongest housing markets are in the East Coast corridor between Philadelphia and New York City.

Only one is in the Southeast, and some of Shreveport's appreciation can be attributed to the relocation falling Hurricane Katrina. None of the cities out West made the top 10, but neither did they make the bottom 10.

Weakest Markets of the '00s
Median Prices in Thousands of Dollars
2000 3Q 2009 Change Change Per Year
Cape Coral-Fort Myers, Fla. 97.4 98.0 0.62% 0.06%
Atlanta-Sandy Springs-Marietta, Ga. 131.2 129.4 -1.37% -0.14%
Akron, Ohio 110.1 107.2 -2.63% -0.26%
Youngstown-Warren-Boardman, Ohio-Penn. 74.1 70.7 -4.59% -0.46%
Cleveland-Elyria-Mentor, Ohio 125.1 115.8 -7.43% -0.74%
Toledo, Ohio 104.0 88.3 -15.10% -1.51%
Grand Rapids, Mich. 114.9 97.1 -15.49% -1.55%
Canton-Massillon, Ohio 107.8 89.3 -17.16% -1.72%
Lansing-E. Lansing, Mich. 111.2 86.6 -22.12% -2.21%
Saginaw-Saginaw Township North, Mich. 80.2 61.4 -23.44% -2.34%

With eight of the 10 weakest markets hailing from the Midwest, it is fairly clear that the steady decline of home prices in that region is neither a new or a short-lived phenomenon.

It is somewhat surprising to see Atlanta and Cape Coral barely making the list, but this is indicative of how high prices went in places like Vegas and Phoenix before they fell 30 to 40 percent in the past two years.

Now, if you slap a 6-7 percent mortgage on these median homes, and then 2-3 percent inflation, you are looking at "a lost decade" for even the strongest markets.

How has your market fared over the past 10 years? What about the next 10?
Add Your Comment

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)

1. AJP on Wednesday, Dec 23rd at 12:08:PM said...

What idiot wrote this article?? The say the incoming Bush adminstration? The elections were not until Nov of 2000! In 1999 I was more worried about the pervert in the White House.

2. BILL on Thursday, Dec 24th at 01:36:PM said...

DOES ANYONE KNOW THAT THE HOUSING COSTS IN 8 OF THE 10 BEST MARKETS WERE ABOUT 65% LOWER THAN THE MEDIAM HOUSEHOLD PRICES TO BEGIN WITH. WHO IN THE HELL WANTS TO LIVE IN WV, BALTIMORE, SCRANTON, ETC?

3. Carl Johnson on Thursday, Dec 24th at 01:57:PM said...

We live about 40 miles north of Detroit and I can confirm that we are living in a disasterous "nuclear winter" here. Forty five percent of the adult residents of Detroit are unemployed right now. We have thousanads of professional electrical and mechanical engineers with masters degrees in engineering that have been without a job for two years. They're being replaced by transplant engineers from India and China that will do the job for one-third the money. Our home has lost 50 percent of it's value during the past five years. It's incredibly bad here. Happy Christmas!

4. Marc Johnstone on Thursday, Dec 24th at 02:11:PM said...

Still, with all of those engineers out of work, the government is pushing for more students to go into science.
Go to law school, my friend, go to law school

5. John Sudduth on Thursday, Dec 24th at 02:27:PM said...

Your companys are moving to Right-to-Work states in the South.
Get rid of your unions and you will recover.

6. ARLENE on Thursday, Dec 24th at 02:42:PM said...

raised in michigan when had pride in henry ford,appreciated the good life the great legacy and most progessive city in world. too bad progress changed from ingratitude to selfishness, jealousy, greed and laziness. offering america the same consequences ? rather have principles then to suffer those consequences.work ethics turned to yuk !!change ? suck it up and work it out.

7. dave on Thursday, Dec 24th at 02:44:PM said...

you can thank obama and your stupid unions.. too bad. ha ha

8. Carol Ann Benjamin on Thursday, Dec 24th at 02:49:PM said...

I truly wish you all the best in 2010.

9. Roger on Thursday, Dec 24th at 03:08:PM said...

I am really sorry to hear that. We moved from Troy to the Charlotte, NC area 2 years ago. And I thought things were really bad then. Hang in there and here's to a MUCH better 2010!

10. Donjuan on Thursday, Dec 24th at 03:23:PM said...

Run And Fast.

11. sJENKINS on Thursday, Dec 24th at 03:45:PM said...

These lasts few years have been rough on everyone. I understand your feelings. This situation is making everyone stronger, we can get through these times by helping each other. Don't give up because trouble don't last always. please hold on to your faith! For Christmas we had to be creative, because we didn't have alot to give our kids, but it's okay. The greatest gift is life! Mr. Carl, 2010 has got to be a great year! Celebrate the New Year, creatively! Merry Christmas from my family to yours!

12. John Doe on Thursday, Dec 24th at 03:47:PM said...

I sold my house in 48187 (30 miles West of Detroit) This June. It was a fixer upper in a nice area when I bought it, but I still lost my shirt...probably lost $100k in renovations and decline in value. I was able to sell if for what I owed and the comissions, I got the heck out while I could. I don't see things getting better there any time soon...Oh yeah...I'm one of those unemployed engineers.

13. Steve Lawson on Thursday, Dec 24th at 03:50:PM said...

I feel our government should do more to help Michigian. We bailed out
the banks and Wall St. but they done very little to help your state.
We can send millions of dollars overseas to assist with global warming
and yet your state is in a horrible condition. Mr. Obama, its all about
JOBS.
Concerned in NC

14. chuck on Thursday, Dec 24th at 04:15:PM said...

carl, hang in there things will get better. the real estate market will turn around, i live in florida and can appreciate your concern. my property values have tanked as well, my retirement plan. then best for the new year, and merry christmas from the deep deep south

15. abur on Thursday, Dec 24th at 04:20:PM said...

I recommend you move.

16. XerxesXXVI on Thursday, Dec 24th at 04:32:PM said...

Maybe those labor unions that drove up the wages should have been abolished years ago. You cannot honestly believe that paying employees $40+ an hour for a job that should be $20 or less per hour would not ruin the auto industry. Sorry for the non-union workers in Detroit, but it was inevitable.

17. Jorge on Thursday, Dec 24th at 05:04:PM said...

WE NEED TO TRACK DOWN THE ANTI-AMERICAN WHO HIRED THEM TO TAKE OUR PLACE.

18. Bob Bodenstein on Thursday, Dec 24th at 05:24:PM said...

And thew greatest gift of all for the Detroit area.You have the Lions!

19. Bob on Thursday, Dec 24th at 05:54:PM said...

I wonder, did you vote for Bush in 2000, and 2004 ?

20. Mike on Thursday, Dec 24th at 06:24:PM said...

So move... oh i know, it's not that easy. Right?

72 Comments / 4 Pages

Poll

Rob Hahn asked, now you get to answer: What is your attitude towards owning a home vs. renting longterm?

Most Popular Stories

Follow Us

Local Homes for Sale