71

COMMENTS

PRINT

TEXT SIZE:

A A A

Home prices aren't the only thing that has plummeted recently. So, too, has the value of home improvement projects, according to Remodeling magazine.

Overall, homeowners can expect to see just 63.8 percent of their remodeling dollars added to the value of their home, according the the magazine's annual Remodeling Cost vs. Value Report. That's down a whopping 26 percent from the peak return of 86.7 percent in 2005. It's also the fourth consecutive year that the return on remodeling has dropped.

"Three or four years ago, a $50,000 or $100,000 kitchen was a sensible investment," Kermit Baker, director of the Joint Center for Housing Studies at Harvard University, told Remodeling. "Housing prices were increasing 6 percent, 8 percent or 10 percent a year. So you were adding to the value and letting the equity build up."

Not anymore. The Joint Center predicts home improvement jobs will decline 9 percent and remodeling will drop 3.5 to 4.5 percent in 2010.

The remodeling projects that will get done during the coming year mirror the mood of the market - robust is no longer a must.

Instead of granite countertops and designer fixtures, homeowners have become more practical, opting for replacing the roof, installing energy efficient windows or making small cosmetic changes, such as a new entryway door.

Homeowners trying to sell their property are concentrating on changes to make their home stand out in a market with too much inventory and not enough buyers. Even these owners are focusing on less expensive projects that improve their home's curb appeal.

So what home improvement projects provide the most bang for the buck? According to the report, they include:

- Installing a steel entry door costs an average $1,172 and returns $1,470 in resale value. It's not only the least expensive project on the survey, it's the only one that returned more than its cost at 128.9 percent.

- Adding an attic bedroom remains one of the best return on investment projects, returning 83.1 percent of its cost.

- Finding the cost of adding interior space prohibitive, homeowners are looking outdoors. A wood deck costing $10,634, returns 80.6 percent - about 10 percent more than a more expensive composite product.

- Installing vinyl siding not only returns 79.9 percent of its cost, it also improves curb appeal for a reasonable price. The average project cost $10,607.

- A minor kitchen remodel priced at $21,411 will get the homeowner back $16,773 or 78.3 percent.

- Replacing worn out windows with energy-efficient wood or vinyl models also has a good return. The example projects cost about $11,000 and returned approximately 77 percent.
Add Your Comment

Tags: home improvement, kitchen, remodeling, return on investment

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)

1. Rayanne on Friday, Jan 1st at 05:11:AM said...

Remodeling one's home is not done only for a dollar for dollar return. It maintains the integrity of the home by keeping it in good condition, therefore adding to its overall value. Also, for future on the market sales, a remodeled home tells potential buyers that this house was worth the investment and that the current owners have been taking care of it. Lastly, a remodeled home gives a great deal of pleasure to the people currently inhabiting it, making life in that home easier, more efficient and more comfortable.

2. Sal Realtor on Monday, Jan 4th at 09:09:PM said...

Rayanne you make a lot of sense:
Although if someone has the enough money, the item that has the highest impact on appraised value of a home is...square footage. The bigger the home, the more it's worth. The exception is, there must be other homes within one mile radius that are similar in size to your home. If your home is much larger, than it won't gain as much value. Of course, room additions and expansions are expensive. Contact a Realtor in your area to discuss room additions if you plan on adding square footage to sell your home. If you,re in the Inland Empire you may email me at WeMakeDreams@homtmail.com, to duscuss your project. This is the best time to sell your home if your planning on buying another home. thanks!

3. Terry Arnold on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 02:14:PM said...

Not sure what the premise of remodeling is from this article. If one's kitchen is falling apart, pipes leaking, etc. etc., should be ignore the mess just because the return on remodeling has been dropping?? People are staying in thier homes longer, much longer than they used to. When it comes time to replace a sagging wall, or cracked concrete flooring, or pool and roof corrections, what is one to do?? To me the article made no sense. After 47 yrs. in the same home, I did some major remodeling. Most of the work had to be done.
Value of my home wasn't an issue in my deciding whether or not to remodel/update.

4. Raul on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 02:40:PM said...

You did not get the article!! they are not saying , NOT to remodel if you have to; ; they are saying that years ago, a seller tried to up date for NEW and more modern furniture, appliances etc , to raise the value , in case he would sell the property; now, people are actually doing minor adjustments, but never was a mention to "NOT to fix what has to be done..
Read it again...

5. Margie Murphy on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 02:30:PM said...

I agree with the need for home improvements vs cost return at resale. What happened to remodeling a bathroom, especially a master bath? We really need to move a commode in an upstairs carpeted master bath. Does anyone have any input regarding moving or leaving it where it is. I want to enjoy my home and the tiny shower, huge jacuzzi which is hardly ever used, and two small closets needs to go. I am not planning on making a TAJ MAHAL, but would like something anyone would be happy with.

6. lynn on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 03:03:PM said...

I agree with you Terry so true.

7. contractor on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 03:06:PM said...

terry arnold cannot read

8. darla on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 04:13:PM said...

i COMPLETELY agree

9. Jim J on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 08:25:PM said...

Don't confuse Remodeling with Maintenance. If your kitchen is " is falling apart, pipes leaking, etc. etc.," then that is a maintenance issue and must be dealt with.

10. tamkis on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 06:30:PM said...

Amen Terry! Listening and believing media hype and #s is S-T-U-P-I-D... and most everyone does it. It sho ain't duh Gospel!!

11. Barron on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 07:14:PM said...

I have to agree, remodeling is the right way to go. The issue is where do you invest your money in your house to get the most out of it? As a Kitchen & Bath designer and remodeler, I have found more people spending thier hard earned money in these rooms to increase thier value, but to also make thier current living condtions much more desirable.
It's hard to do all of this if you go into the "Big Box" showrooms, becuase you may end up with a design that really doesn't work and is no real improvement.
You must make sure you get your bang for your buck these days, so you really have to spend the time researching both materials and client references before you hire anyone to start such a project.

12. gdewizard on Friday, Feb 5th at 01:08:AM said...

Terry and others
Often people were remodeling JUST to add value to their homes insted of doing it because they wanted to inprove it for themselves. They would select overpriced items just because a real estate person said it would make more money in resale, not because they saw a need for them. If you have a kitchen or bath that is satisfactory to you, then don't do anything about it. If it does not suit your purposes, then concider it but do it intelegenty, not to impress buyers but to serve your purposes. I have been remodeling homes for 30 years. Often people go overboard. Also plan carefully. I design and show people what they are getting before they do major repairs using specialized desifgn programs. I often advise them to not go overboard. You can do things nicely without breaking the bank, you need to do them within your means. But do not go for mearly an increace in equity, do it for an increace in your comfort and use. Greg Cobaltwizard.com

13. D on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 02:46:PM said...

It seems to me that a basement re-model is the cheapest way to add living space. I don't see it mentioned in the article.

14. eva webb on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 03:11:PM said...

For those that are looking to stay in their homes and wish to makes some needed improvements, the plus side is that with this drop in remodeling and building etc., the cost of building supplies has also dropped. So it really makes sense to make those improvements now because when the economy does come back your return on investment will be that much better. For me, since I was able to purchase my home for $60,000 less than what it appraised for because of this depressed market, I really cannot go wrong. I definitely plan on making improvements throughout the next year.

15. canepa carpentry on Monday, Jan 4th at 04:06:PM said...

If you are looking for a good carpenter to do any of these jobs send me an email. I am a head carpenter and supervisor for finest kitchens and remodeling and I also have my own off shoot company for smaller jobs troubleshooting etc.

Nick @ncanepajr@aol.com

16. Jimmer on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 03:32:PM said...

Don't spend your money if you don't intend to live there and enjoy what you did.

17. Al Phillips on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 08:03:PM said...

When I took out a loan to redo the kitchen the banker was saying "what a great asset" it would be I responded with "a house is a liability not an asset,I have to keep it repaired,pay the taxes,water bill,electric and heat bill,etc." she ws taken aback,had never considered that.You are right ,best to enjoy your home.

18. Laura on Thursday, Jan 14th at 03:58:PM said...

I totally agree with you- fix the important things so your hourse does not fall apart - keep it neat- clean - and at least marketable without broken tiles or leaking ceilings holes in walls -cracks etc.
But spending a fortune to fix/change things and you don't plan to stay
there for a lengthly time is a waste of time and money because the next buyer will probably not like your improvements anyway and change them.

19. b.g. on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 03:17:PM said...

@terry arnold
article is talking about remodeling not fixing. READ!!!

20. kluji on Sunday, Jan 3rd at 04:14:PM said...

I have an article fro years back written by these same people from harvard that said you HAVE to invest in real estate and that real estate wopuld APPRECIATE in valuse for at least another 20 years and the article gives every tom dick and harry reason why it will continue top appreciate. I save the article because I was very BEARISH real estate and equities and had taken bearish financial postions in both markets and thought it would be nice to save the article so i could pull it out a few years later and wave it in their faces. I had a feeling they would show up once both markets crashed and talk as if they saw it coming and what people should have done yahdah yahdah yahdah, They, this harvard group of experts, were dead wrong and i have the proof. Also, take note, harvards expert investors who control the largest college endowment have lost billions upon billions to the point where they have even stopped a real estate project dead in its tracks. Again, these so called experts were DEAD WRONGl !!!!!! all they do is take the current trend and extrapulate it out into the future and then give you every fundamental reason to back it up. I guess that makes them feel better!

71 Comments / 4 Pages

 

Add your comments

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog post. First-time comment? Enter your name and e-mail address, and you'll receive an email confirming your comment and issuing you a password. Your name will be displayed with your comment, but your email address will not. To create additional comments, use that same password. Comments may contain up to three live links; line breaks and paragraphs will automatically be converted to HTML.

Poll

Rob Hahn asked, now you get to answer: What is your attitude towards owning a home vs. renting longterm?
Owning a home is still a great way to invest for the long term - it's still at the center of the American Dream9126 (66.2%)
Ownership can be overrated. It's better to rent long term than extend yourself financially just for the sake of owning a home.4659 (33.8%)

Most Popular Stories

Follow Us

Local Homes for Sale